Can a 3D Phone be a Good Phone?
Thursday, October 20, 2011 6:16Both HTC and LG have released 3D phone contracts – the LG Optimus 3D and the HTC Evo 3D – so how do they fare as phones without any of the 3D technology. After all these devices are phones essentially and should be judged as a phone foremost and piece of technology that can take 3D photos afterwards.
The LG doesn’t get off to a great start – it is quite thick at 11.9mm and not the most attractive of devices with its large body and completely black rubberised finish. The phone’s only positive or interesting feature is the chrome band with the dual lens on the back. The HTC Evo is slightly more attractive and HTC have gone for a similar large device, though have broken up the back with a bronze strip on the back – slightly better but no pretty.
The HTC and the LG have 4.3in screens that both show 3D images on a 480x800p screen. The LGs screen does seem to be that bit brighter that the HTCs and offers a little more clarity in high light. To be honest both phones are lacklustre when compared to their 3D equivalents and you feel both companies have sacrificed quality thinking the 3D will be the selling point.
The LG and the HTC both also have dual core processors to enable them to produce the heavy power needed for 3D images. However, when using both phones with 3D on or off, both the devices seem sluggish, with the HTC seeming far slower than the Sensation from which it takes a lot of its components.
The LG does seem faster, but its Android 2.2 operating system is a little limited opposed to that of the HTC, which uses 2.3. This means the HTC gives a more modern feel, though the LG does feel a little more responsive. LG also has added a number of nice extras to the LG user interface that give it a little bit of a lead on the HTC in this area also.
Both the devices can be upgraded to store 32GB via a SD card and both have the usual array of media players and other such entertainment apps.
Overall we would choose the LG Optimus 3D contract as it just seems to be a little bit better put together than the HTC Evo 3D. The HTC seems a lot further off the pace than the LG and is far from nearly as good as the 2D HTCs, which is a shame, whereas the LG doesn’t lack as much in the area of comparison.